US judge allows lawsuits over Monsanto's Roundup to proceed to trial

14 July, 2018, 00:33 | Author: Kara Nash
  • CC BY 2.0

The herbicide came under increasing scrutiny after the France-based International Agency for Research on Cancer, which is part of the World Health Organization, classified it as a "probable human carcinogen" in 2015. But he said a reasonable jury could conclude, based on the findings of four experts he allowed, that glyphosate can cause cancer in humans.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency concluded in September 2017 that the chemical is likely "not" carcinogenic to humans, provided it was used in accordance with label directions.

On Tuesday, a federal judge ruled there was sufficient evidence for a jury to hear the case.

The California state judge who handles the most Roundup cases posted to her docket that she was attending the hearings before Chhabria in March. It has since been sold in more than 160 countries.

Roundup, made by U.S. giant Monsanto, is sprayed on gardens and parks and is used by farmers producing food crops.

In its defense, Monsanto said the allegations were not true.

However, Monsanto said there's no evidence of a connection between their product and cancer.


The company said its stance was backed up by more than 800 scientific studies and reviews.

The plaintiffs will now have to show Roundup caused cancer in individual people whose cases will be selected for test trials, a phase Chhabria called a "daunting challenge".

Brent Wisner, an attorney for Johnson, told jurors during his opening statement on Monday that his client sprayed large quantities of Roundup for two years at his job at a San Francisco Bay Area school district. When the wind was gusty, it would cover his face, Wisner said. In one incident, the hose attached to the tank got broken and the herbicide soaked Johnson's entire body.

Dewayne Johnson, a 46-year-old father of two, says he is sick because of contact with Roundup, the top-selling weed killer made by the US company. In 2014, he was diagnosed with non-Hodgkins lymphoma.

George Lombardi, attorney for Monsanto, said the disease takes years to develop and thereby argued that Johnson's cancer started prior his use of Roundup.

Another federal judge presiding over hundreds of lawsuits like Johnson's is deciding whether the claim that Roundup weed killer can cause cancer is supported by good science.

Recommended:



Popular

Xherdan Shaqiri: Liverpool sign Stoke forward after triggering release clause
Matt Le Tissier has reacted to Xherdan Shaqiri reportedly being on the verge of joining Liverpool . I want to improve myself too, I want to be with the best and I want to win titles.

China's trade surplus with USA swells in June
Last week, the United States and China introduced tariffs of 25 percent on $34 billion of each other's exports. Its trade surplus with the U.S. over the same period was $133.76bn, up from $117.51bn past year .

France, Italy reject Trump's claim on North Atlantic Treaty Organisation spending boost World 08:51
But he did not rule out recognising Rissia's annexation of Crimea. At an emergency session, Trump also threatened a U.S. pull out. In what sounded like a Johnson endorsement, Mr.

British-US trade deal possible after Brexit, say May and Trump
Thousands of people waving banners and banging pots and pans took to the streets of London on Friday to protest against U.S. It was one of more than a hundred protests police expected during Trump's four-day trip.

British Novichok survivor Charlie Rowley regains consciousness: Salisbury District Hospital
Public Health England also offered advice for people who may have visited one of five areas identified by police. Basu said the severe reaction of Sturgess and Rowley meant they must have received a high dose of Novichok.

Rosenstein says 12 Russian intel officers indicted in special counsel's probe
And the announcement came at the same time that Trump and the first lady were meeting at Windsor Castle with the Queen. Attorney General Rod Rosenstein convened a press conference at the Justice Department on Friday.

President Trump Reportedly Threatened to Pull the U.S. Out of North Atlantic Treaty Organisation
Add Donald Trump as an interest to stay up to date on the latest Donald Trump news, video, and analysis from ABC News. Trump has described the spending situation as "disproportionate and not fair to the taxpayers of the United States".

Endangered Blue Whale Illegally Slaughtered by Icelandic Whalers, Claim Activists
Blue whales can reach up to 33 metres in length and have been protected by the International Whaling Commission since 1966. The government of Iceland confirmed that "blue whales are protected under Icelandic law with their capture prohibited".

Eclipse 2018: Is there a solar eclipse today on Friday 13th?
This partial eclipse began at 7:18 IST on July 13, reached its maximum magnitude of 0.3367 at 8:31 IST and ended at 09:43 IST. The visual of Solar Eclipse will not be visible to many and only a small part of Antartica would be able to watch the eclipse.

Trump brings his chaotic road show to Britain
Trump's undiplomatic attack on May, his host, will likely raise the temperature around an already controversial visit. Trump said that one of them, former Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson, "would be a great Prime Minister".