Duke Med alumnus wins lawsuit against Trump for blocking him on Twitter

25 May, 2018, 11:25 | Author: Kara Nash
  • Donald Trump Cannot Block People on Twitter U.S. Judge Rules

A US judge has ruled that US President Donald Trump can not block people viewing his tweets.

Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald, of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of NY, ruled that Trump's Twitter account is a public forum.

However, the court ruled that the president is a public figure who has used his personal twitter account to make political announcements and that his feed is, indeed, a "public forum" and thus protected by the first amendment. "The answer to both questions is no", she concluded. In an email to The Associated Press, department spokesperson Kerri Kupec said, "We respectfully disagree with the court's decision and are considering our next steps".

The case was brought forward by seven Twitter users who have been blocked on Twitter by the U.S. President.

Other media reports said the judge advised Mr Trump to mute critics if he doesn't want to see their activities, but they would be able to see and reply his own tweets.

A Twitter feed is more than one person's opinions because others can reply to tweets, and those replies are available for anyone to see.

In other words, Trump can continue to tweet unhindered, regardless of whatever happens in comment threads to previous tweets.

However, the US Department of Justice opposed with the court decision.


Considering Trump's position as a public official, a federal judge on Thursday ruled that he can not legally block his followers on Twitter based on their political views.

In what might just be one of the more freaky tech stories of the week, the judge's decision is the result of a case brought against the President by a group of Twitter users he'd blocked.

Trump's lawyers and the White House director of social networks, Daniel Scavino, said the president had a right to decide who had access to his private twitter account.

The distinction between muting and blocking showed the judge applied a subtle, but sophisticated, understanding of Twitter and social media, said Aaron Caplan, a professor at Loyola Law School of Los Angeles specializing in constitutional law. "If all goes well, Hollywood will immortalize him as an evildoer who got his comeuppance".

The Trump case is a little bit different because Twitter doesn't give anyone the ability to post comments directly on Trump's Twitter page.

Buchwald also disagreed with the contention of the defense that injunctive relief can never be awarded against the president, but she decided that she didn't need to "enter that legal thicket at this time". As such, if he blocks people and thereby prevents them from seeing his messages, he is breaking the First Amendment.

However, the Federal District Court for the Southern District of NY found that this was not the case.

It's not clear, as of this writing, how many Twitter users Trump has blocked - it could be a few dozen, it could be thousands. In last year's ruling about Facebook blocking, the judge held that public officials could do a certain amount of content moderation, provided that it was done in a content-neutral manner.

Recommended:



Popular

NFL announces national anthem policy
That's not going to play well in the locker rooms of the league, and not among a sizable contingent of the stands, either.

Battlefield V Will Not Include a Premium Pass
One of them will be told from the perspective of a female Nowegian Resistance fighter, battling against the German occupation. But hey, the lack of actual gameplay shown didn't prevent EA from making Battlefield 5 available for pre-order already .

Kilauea lava flows threaten geothermal power plant
Puna Geothermal, owned by Nevada's Ormat Technologies, was shut down shortly after Kilauea began spewing lava on May 3. Earlier this month officials removed a flammable gas called pentane from the plant to reduce the chance of explosions.

North Korea Gets Ready to Destroy Its Main Nuclear Test Site
But there also is the risk of a diplomatic failure that would allow the North to revive and advance its weapons program. On Seoul's streets on Wednesday, South Koreans were divided on whether they thought Pyongyang was honest .

Call Of Duty: Black Ops 4 Battle Royale Mode Will Be 'Blackout'
Therefore, the new healing system is going to slow down combat and the way players approach different combat scenarios. Call of Duty's new Blackout Battle Royale Mode is the one thing that a lot of Call of Duty fans want to hear about.

Senate backs effort to restore 'net neutrality'
In surveys , solid majorities say they support the principle of net neutrality generally, and the FCC's rules in particular. But, he cautioned, it remains unclear how many voters will actually be motivated by net neutrality to go to the polls .

Facebook's Zuckerberg to meet European Parliament over privacy
He might get tougher questions in Brussels, where an assertive new European data protection law comes into effect on May 25. Facebook was largely unscathed by Zuckerberg's 10 hours of testimony before US legislators in April.

McAllen Police Honors Fallen Officers
Members of the 177th Basic Recruit Class lit a candle and then read a narrative about how the fallen heroes died. In the event of inclement weather, the ceremony will be moved indoors to the Training Academy auditorium.

Amazon Prime Members Are Getting New Discounts at Whole Foods
Eligible Prime members also receive 5 percent back on Whole Foods Market purchases when using the Amazon Prime Rewards Visa Card. Earlier this year, Amazon launched free, two-hour delivery on Whole Foods groceries through its Prime Now service in 10 cities.

Ramadan Starts on May 17th in Most Muslim Nations
The Iftar is the meal served at the end of the day during Ramadan , to break the day's fast. In essence, it is a period of spiritual growth attained through prayer and self-control.